Hunter
I want you to understand where I’m coming from and how I evaluate your situation.
You posted here first six years ago about suspicions. What you had then was pretty thin and I suggested you investigate but be realistic about what you found out. After some time, you concluded that there was no infidelity going on. Based on what you shared at the time, I agreed.
Then now – six years later – you discover direct and clear evidence of an affair. No question about it. Same man as you suspected six years ago.
We can contemplate when an affair becomes an affair. Is it when she or om first hit on the other, the first flirtatious message, the first hand-holding, the first kiss, the first groping, the first sex... What I think the logical conclusion we would make – based on what you share – is that something had started when you were suspicious and that it has been going on since. What that "something" was back six years ago... is that really relevant per se?
Best-case the affair wasn’t consummated six years ago, but the seeds were sown. If the first sex was 2 years ago... well... that’s 4 years she allowed the situation to fester without doing anything to stop it.
Frankly – you can select a date at any time in the last six years ago and state the affair started then – if you base the start-date on the first physical contact (be that sex, groping, hand-holding or whatever).
Personally – I think an affair starts way before the first button is unbuttoned and the first zipper unzipped. It starts when the wayward spouse decides to enter a situation where then know a line is crossed or likely to be crossed. It starts the very second she went on a drive with him one lunch "to talk in private", away from the eyes of others at the office. The minute she didn’t push his hand off her thigh under the table at the bar at the company party.
When did that happen? It could be after that six-year date your suspicions arose. Heck... it could also have been a couple of years earlier. After all suspicions are based on something, and some things take time to become noticeable.
So this is one issue I see in your situation:
You don’t really know what you are dealing with, BUT everything strongly indicates a long-term office affair.
-
Do you really think your wife can end a six year relationship just like that? Wouldn’t that in itself be a concern? IMHO the odds are higher that this rekindles than that this ends. Let’s say OM and W divorce in the next months... think OM will let your wife alone?
Infidelity is like a vampire. You really need to expose it to daylight, and then ram a stake through it to keep it down.
-
You say you are in LEO, right? Imagine there was a string of five bank robberies in your area where the perpetrator is described as six foot tall, stocky and wears red pants. Then you capture a bank-robber in the act – six feet, stocky... but wearing brown khakis. You can’t connect him to the other robberies, but once he’s in custody the robberies stop. Even with no proof it’s a pretty tight deduction that this guy did the other five before switching pants. It’s then your task to connect him to the other five, and even if you can’t then ensure he gets his sentence for what can be proved.
Your wife’s situation allows comparable deductions. We know she had an affair. We know who OM is. What we don’t know is when, how and for how long.
Our experience strongly suggests – like in 99% of instances – that the total truth is never attainable at first. Nothing you share about your wife indicates a real "come to Jesus" moment where she realizes the truth is required. Instead we get a typical description of minimizing. "Only" once, "only" a hand-job, "only" oral, "only" since April last year...
Now – this might all be true. Just like maybe a couple of years from now when khaki-pants is doing time you get a new bank-robbery with a six-foot, stocky, red-pants thief... But you really need to verify it all.
A key to reconciling is realizing what you are reconciling from. Big difference in a 72 month affair and an 18 month one... You need to understand why they were OK with being flirty for about 55 months before she "only" gave him a hand-job. You need to be convinced you know what started it, how it progressed and what funneled each ongoing step.
Your wife is NOT allowed the luxury of thinking she got away with 55 months, or not letting you know about the PIV sex, or the time she had him in your house, or the time they did it in her car, or the time they were caught at the office or whatever.
Reconciliation comes from total honesty. I don’t think you have anything close to that as-is.
-
Your WW mental state. There is nothing mentally logical about infidelity. Again – if I refer to the bank-robber analogy – no logical or sensible man choses that career. Yet that doesn’t make them crazy. I find it "convenient" for your wife that she can be logical enough to have an affair – possibly for over 6 years, hide it from you, hide it from colleagues, finance it, hide the time it took from your family... and NOW she cracks...
Sorry – but I tie that a lot more into some effort to control you. To prevent a divorce, to prevent you pressing for the answers you should be needing. I take mental health seriously, but I don’t think your wife is as mentally weak as you think.
-
The general consensus here on SI is that a WS and the OP can’t work together. One or the other needs to change jobs. He might be in another department in another building, but there is too much opportunity to interact. It’s like expecting a recovering alcoholic to work as a bartender.
Then there is the more-or-less given truth that others at work KNOW.
What about the annual Christmas party? You OK with her being there? You OK with the snide looks and sniggers if you attend with her? You OK with seeing OM at the other end of the room, laughing with management?
Think this constant trigger helps you and the marriage recover?
-
You mention a covenant marriage. It’s been suggested that no matter what you decide eventually then you use this opportunity to have some form of acceptance of divorce terms ready. That could be a simple statement where she agrees to a divorce without the hassle of a covenant marriage. But I guess the fear of her mental state protects her from those consequences.
Hunter – I see you in a very precarious situation where you are making things harder for yourself. You are working from the premise that you can save your marriage.
You can’t...
What might save your marriage is if BOTH of you were to work at saving it. That can’t be done from half-truths and rug-sweeping. Your wife had an AFFAIR. She willingly and freely flirted with, conversed with, met with, had sex with and committed to another man. Not only that – but AT THE VERY LEAST this has been building up for over SIX years. There is no "nice-ing" this away. This is nitty-gritty and dirty work. First in totally killing the affair and then from a base of total truth. Until you have that truth, your wife is placing just as much effort into protecting her affair as she might be in saving the marriage.
I hope you see I do think you two can reconcile. Only that right now, I don’t think you have what is required. No matter how much YOU might want to reconcile.